10 Easy Diabetic Cookie Recipes – Sugar Free & Low Carb

In this detailed guide, explore the process of creating flavourful sugar-free diabetic cookies. Alongside my top tips, you’ll find a collection of 10 diabetic-friendly cookie recipes that skillfully balance taste with considerations for managing diabetes.

pin for 10 diabetic friendly cookies low carb and sugar free

Cookies and biscuits are an absolute staple snack in this house and I love creating new and tasty recipes that also consider blood sugar-conscious choices. However, when looking for diabetic-friendly cookies, finding delectable treats that cater to both taste and health considerations can sometimes be hard to find. Well no more!

In this article, I delve into my tips and guidelines for creating flavourful diabetic cookies that not only satisfy the sweet tooth but also factor in blood sugar control.

What is a Diabetic Cookie?

A diabetic cookie is a type of cookie or biscuit taht has been specifically crafted for individuals living with diabetes. These cookies are made with ingredients that support managing blood sugar levels. They will typically use sugar substitutes or alternatives, whole grain flours, and healthier fats in place of refined flours and sugar.

Diabetic cookies aim to provide a tasty sweet treat without causing significant spikes in blood glucose. Additionally, they may be lower in carbohydrates and overall sugar content compared to traditional cookies. It’s essential for individuals living with diabetes to monitor carbohydrate intake and by opting for more diabetic-friendly options it can help to meet these dietary needs and health goals.

How to make a diabetic cookie without sacrificing flavour

Making diabetic cookies without sacrificing flavour is absolutely achievable with a few thoughtful adjustments. As in all my recipes on WHK, I have carefully considered lots of aspects to ensure the tastiest and most delicious cookies to support your diabetes management.

But here are some tips and general rules I follow when creating a diabetic-friendly cookie or biscuit

Choose the Right Sweeteners

  • Experiment with sugar substitutes like xylitol, stevia, erythritol, or sucralose to add sweetness without affecting blood sugar levels.
  • Individual responses to sugar substitutes can vary, so it’s essential to choose one that works for your specific needs.
  • My go-to for all my sweet recipes is Xyltiol as it has a low glycemic index, does not raise blood sugars and has a great taste profile too.

Read my comprehensive guide below all about sugar substitutes widely available in the UK

Sugar Substitutes and Diabetes Management

The world of sugar substitutes and type 1 diabetes can be confusing. This guide explores substitutes in the UK and diabetes management

Try Natural Sweeteners as a sugar replacement instead

  • Opt for natural sweeteners like mashed ripe bananas or unsweetened apple puree to add natural sweetness and moisture.

Balance Flavours

  • Enhance the flavour profile with ingredients like vanilla extract, cinnamon, nut butters or other spices to compensate for the reduced sweetness.
  • Consider flavour combinations and what goes well together like peanut butter and banana, hazelnut and chocolate.

Incorporate Nuts and Seeds

  • Add chopped nuts or seeds for texture and a nutty flavour.
  • Almonds, walnuts, flaxseeds and chia seeds are excellent choices, which will also increase the fibre content in every cookie

Choose Whole Grains

  • Use a whole grain flour like almond flour, coconut flour, or oat flour instead of refined flours.
  • They not only add a richer flavour and added nutrients but are also kinder on blood sugars, helping to avoid big spikes.

Opt for Dark Chocolate

  • Use high-quality, dark chocolate with at least 70% cocoa content.
  • Dark chocolate adds depth and richness without an excessive amount of sugar and is, therefore, gentler on blood glucose levels

Experiment with Fruit Zest

  • Citrus zest, such as orange or lemon, can impart a burst of flavour to your cookies without adding extra sugar.

Mindful Use of Fruits

  • Include naturally sweet fruits like berries, which bring sweetness and antioxidants without causing a significant spike in blood sugar.

Don’t Overlook Fats

  • Healthy fats, such as those from oils, nuts and seeds can contribute to a satisfying flavour profile.

Consider Sugar-Free Syrups

  • Explore sugar-free syrups or extracts, such as maple or vanilla, to enhance sweetness without compromising on flavour.

By carefully selecting ingredients and experimenting with different combinations, you can create delicious diabetic-friendly cookies that satisfy your sweet tooth without sacrificing flavour.

Can I make diabetic cookies that are also gluten-free?

Yes you can!

It’s definitely possible to make diabetic-friendly and gluten-free cookies. When creating cookies, all you need to pay attention to is the ingredients you use to ensure they are suitable for both a diabetic and gluten-free diet.

However, I have done all the hard work for you as all of the tasty cookie and biscuit recipes on WHK are gluten-free and diabetic-friendly. I use either individually or a combination of whole grain flours like almond and oat flour to create my delicious gluten-free cookies.

10 Easy Diabetic Cookie Recipes – Low Carb and Sugar Free

Explore this collection of 10 easy-to-follow diabetic cookie recipes that not only satisfy your sweet tooth but are also low in carbs and sugar-free.

These delicious treats are specially crafted to be gluten-free, ensuring they align with diabetic dietary needs while still delivering lots of flavours. And every recipe on this list has undergone thorough testing to ensure the best results. They also include tips and tricks within each recipe to assist you in creating the perfect low-carb cookie.

Get ready to indulge in some tasty delights that cater to both your taste buds and your health goals.

closeup of an almond flour oatmeal chocolate chip cookie

Enjoy these irresistible almond flour oatmeal chocolate chip cookies. They are crumbly, soft, and a perfect diabetic-friendly treat without the added sugar

a pile of oatmeal cookies

If you’re looking to satisfy your sweet tooth without the added sugar, then these sugar-free oatmeal cookies are the perfect treat for you

banana almond flour cookies on a baking tray

These banana almond flour cookies with peanuts are gluten and refined sugar-free and for diabetic carb counting only 2g of carbs per biscuit!

stacked sugar free oat cookies

These super simple sugar-free oat biscuits are quick and easy to make, healthier and kinder on blood sugar levels.

Chocolate Raspberry thumbprint cookie and pot of raspberry jam

These chocolate raspberry thumbprint cookies are fuss-free, use only 1 bowl and are only 2g of (Diabetic) countable carbs per cookie!

closeup of zero carb count almond biscuits stacked in a tin

Are you craving a biscuit but don’t want to have to work out the carb count? Then these quick almond biscuits are just what you need!

peanut butter banana oat cookie cut in half

These easy no added sugar, peanut butter banana oat cookies are naturally gluten-free, suitable for vegans and kinder on blood sugar levels.

spiced ginger biscuits in a bowl

Enjoy the perfect balance of soft and fluffy textures with these low-carb, gluten and sugar-free spiced ginger biscuits!

almond flour chocolate chip cookie in half

These almond flour chocolate chip cookies are low carb, gluten free, super tasty, and sure to satisfy any chocolate biscuit craving.

Stack of easy carb count free cheese biscuits

An Easy Savoury Cheese biscuit that are not only gluten and diabetic carb count free but are also totally moreish thanks to the added umami ingredient!

More tasty recipe round ups to explore:



Whole Hearty Kitchen Logo
Michelle Rorke avatar


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *